Your thoughts about Fëanor | Page 2 | The Tolkien Forum
2001年9月4日 · Originally posted by Tar-Steve for "JERK" read "A**H**E". Feanor was a selfish JERK. He's the embodiment of the very essence of self-center. Even as he died (died!), he loved himself more that his sons (his own children!) and chose to enforce the oath he knew to be without hope instead of...
The Problem of Eagle - can we put an end to it? | Page 2
2008年10月21日 · Well, I suppose Arwen would have objected to Aragorn mooning Sauron anyway. Getting ghost warriors to honour their pledge sounds better in history books ^^...
Who's the Greatest Vala? | Page 2 | The Tolkien Forum
2002年9月15日 · YayGollum,did you see?All think Manwe is the greatest because he is the most powerful Vala.Exactly what I said.But it seemed that Nenya Evenstar didn't read what I had written.:(
The Tolkien Forum
Melkor is clearly nihilistic, basically throwing a cosmic temper tantrum because he can't rule Eru's universe, thus trying to destroy everything. It has to be clear that, even if Melkor had won and somehow not only crushed the Elves , but somehow defeated the Valar and even Eru, that he, Sauron, would eventually have been destroyed too by the ...
Battle between Fëanor and Luthy! | Page 2 | The Tolkien Forum
2002年9月14日 · Originally posted by LúthienTinúviel Ah, well then we agree. :) I think debates about the finer points of Tolkienian history are stimulating and very intructive, but only if Toliien's imagination is respected. I don't have the time of day for …
Who is your favorite in the Fellowship and why? | Page 10
2001年10月16日 · Favourite (male) Elf = Finrod Felagund Favourite (female) Elf = Galadriel Favourite (male) Maia = Olorin Favourite (female) Maia = Uinen Favourite (male) Vala = Aule Favourite (female) Vala = Varda Favourite God = Iluvatar (there's only one!) Favourite Ainur = Olorin Favourite (male)...
A Long-Expected Party | Page 2 | The Tolkien Forum
2002年8月7日 · Originally posted by Maedhros I can't wait. But, who is in the other roster then? I hope this will serve as an example to those who think that debate...
The Divergence upon the Last of the Teleri Discussion Thread
2022年4月29日 · Search titles only By: Search Advanced search…
Which was the most effective? The Doom of Mandos or the Curse …
2003年10月14日 · If I understand you (Gothmog and Alcuin) correctly, you would mean that the sufferings of the noldor is a "natural" consequence of the deeds of Feanor (i.e. the valar did nothing to worsen the situation of the exiled and that they only unveil the course of future events). I don't see any...
The Never Asked Question | Page 3 | The Tolkien Forum
2002年9月10日 · See, that's my problem. Its kind of hard for me to believe that she was a Maia -- she almost killed Melkor, the most powerful Vala, but for the host of...